(Chesterton was against votes for women. Obviously I don't agree with him on that; he clearly didn't know that in the mediaeval European towns and villages on which he looked back so fondly it was quite normal for women to be able to vote. He does say (and I'd love to have confirmation on this) that it was only a minority of women in Britain at that time who wanted the vote, and that it struck him as oddly undemocratic for a minority to expect to overthrow the will of the majority on the question of becoming part of the democratic process. This raises the interesting question of how much allowance we should make in our democratic dealings for the majority not really knowing what they want and having to be told what it is by the minority. But anyway. This is just background for the following quote...)
"But for the moment the essential point is that in self-governing countries this coercion of criminals is a collective coercion. The abnormal person is theoretically thumped by a million fists and kicked by a million feet. if a man is flogged, we all flogged him; if a man is hanged, we all hanged him.* That is the only possible meaning of democracy which can give any meaning to the first two syllables and also to the last two. In this sense each citizen has the high responsibility of a rioter. Every statute is a declaration of war, to be backed by arms. Every tribunal is a revolutionary tribunal. In a republic, all punishment is as sacred and solemn as lynching."
*And one might go on thus; if a country is invaded we all invaded it; if a prisoner is tortured we all tortured him; if a wire is tapped we all tapped it, and so on. [Footnote mine.]
"But for the moment the essential point is that in self-governing countries this coercion of criminals is a collective coercion. The abnormal person is theoretically thumped by a million fists and kicked by a million feet. if a man is flogged, we all flogged him; if a man is hanged, we all hanged him.* That is the only possible meaning of democracy which can give any meaning to the first two syllables and also to the last two. In this sense each citizen has the high responsibility of a rioter. Every statute is a declaration of war, to be backed by arms. Every tribunal is a revolutionary tribunal. In a republic, all punishment is as sacred and solemn as lynching."
*And one might go on thus; if a country is invaded we all invaded it; if a prisoner is tortured we all tortured him; if a wire is tapped we all tapped it, and so on. [Footnote mine.]